Why Did Satellite Stocks Head North Friday?
After a virtual drubbing over the past couple of weeks, the satellite radio stocks of Sirius (SIRI) and XM (XMSR) saw a boost Friday that gave investors a bit of a break, and perhaps even set the tone for a good weekend.
The natural question at this point is, why did this sharp upturn happen? As with anything there can be many answers and theories. Theories from FCC votes being leaked, to shorts covering for the weekend, to market manipulation are all ideas that people seem to love to discuss.
Personally, I look at the upturn in both Sirius and XM and see something interesting. Sirius was up more than XM. Thus, the arbitrage spread actually got larger in the last couple of hours of the day. This activity could give legs to the theory that shorts are covering. One popular arb play if you felt the merger would pass was to go long XM and short SIRI.
I also consider the fact that the Draft Order has been issued, and that there is speculation that we could begin to know commissioner stances by mid next week.
Combine these two theories, and it is possible that we are onto something. How much upside this can deliver is yet to be seen, but Monday will be a day that investors in the sector may want to pay attention.
Even with a nice jump late Friday afternoon, neither equity reached levels of the trading channel that existed for most of the merger process. Thus, satellite radio is still in a bit of “no-mans land” - below the trading channel and above the $1.75 price target of Wienkes. If the equities hold their ground, we may not see a new report from the Goldman Sachs analyst, which was something I was looking for to help establish a bottom. Without an established bottom, there is still some trepidation out there that investors may want to consider.
Over the next few days, some information will become available that may also impact SDARS. OEMs will be reporting June sales early next week. One factor that has satellite watchers nervous has been the continued downtrend in vehicle sales. If a bad trend continues, satellite investors will want to be on top of the news as it begins to come out. Not only will the June sales represent a month, but Q2 as well. With 6 months now gone, this would be the time that analysts would be sharpening their pencils and going through their assumptions. Some analysts have already projected that the retail channel for Sirius will be better than previously assumed. Solid news on the OEM channel will be a focus now as well.
Sector watchers should follow FCC activity, the OEM numbers, the arb spread, as well as the trading volume. Things could be ready for a change, and now is not the time to take your eye off of the ball no matter what your investment strategy.
Position - Long Sirius, Long XM
- Media Meltdown Is Even Worse Than Markets »
- Viacom's Tumble Takes Media Stocks With It »
- Emmis Communications Corporation F2Q09 (Qtr End 08/31/08) Earnings Call Transcript »
- Amazon, Rhapsody Gain in Digital Music Market ; iTunes Still Top Dog »
- Netflix May Dominate The Online Video World, But With What Business Model? »
Get Seeking Alpha Free Stock Alerts by Email!
Get Free Stock Alerts by Email!
ETFs In Focus
-
Editor's Picks
-
Most Popular
- Apocalypse Dow: The Search for Scapegoats
- This Isn't a Bottom, It's a Disturbance in The Force
- Reading the S&P 500's Crashing Waves
- What Would Jim Rogers Do?
- On a Return to Normalcy: Dow 8,500
- Looking Back at Lehman: Lying, Scapegoating and a General Lack of Accountability
- Full list of Editor's Picks »
- Nation's Debt: It's Not Being Rescued, It's Being Moved Around »
- Clueless - Cramer's Mad Money (10/8/08) »
- Cramer Should Be Suspended »
- This Isn't a Bottom, It's a Disturbance in The Force »
- Crazy P/E Ratios »
- Bulls Take a Stand - Cramer's Stop Trading! (10/10/08) »
- Sirius Shares Priced Like Stamps »
- Where We Go from Here: Best and Worst Cases »
- Wall Street Breakfast: Must-Know News »
- Earnings Preview: General Electric »
- Cramer: Dow Could Drop Another 14%, Oil's Going to $50 »
-
Long Ideas
-
Short Ideas
-
Cramer's Picks
- Largest Bond ETF Now Trading At a Massive Discount
- Single Worst Week - Fast Money Recap (10/10/08)
- 'When There's Blood in the Streets', Buy Biotech Stocks
- Midstream MLPs Crashing, Present Opportunity
- A Fresh Look at Shipping Company Stocks
- Panic Selling in InterOil: What Now?
- Potash Corp.: No Liquidity Problems Here
- The Year of the Bear
- Cobalt: More Than Just Blue
- Investors Can Find Comfort in Big Blue
- Full list of Long Ideas »
- The Short Case for General Electric
- Too Late to Short SPY? An Historical Perspective
- Henderson Group: Profit Warning Surprises Short Investors
- Decreasing Chipotle Traffic Could Spell Trouble
- Why I Sold Lowe's Short
- Accor, Host and Marriott: Short Interest Heats Up
- Global Financial Crisis Makes Oil a Great Hedge
- Michael Page International: Stock Down on Market Weakness
- Gaming Stocks Still a Poor Bet - Barron's
- After Coming Rate Cuts, Some Appealing Short ETFs
- Full list of Short Ideas »
- Back Room Deal? - Cramer's Mad Money (10/10/08)
- Prefer a Yield - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/10/08)
- Bulls Take a Stand - Cramer's Stop Trading! (10/10/08)
- Cramer Should Be Suspended
- Clueless - Cramer's Mad Money (10/8/08)
- Torpedo Dry Ships - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/8/08)
- Chocolate Lover - Cramer's Mad Money (10/7/08)
- Yield is King - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/7/08)
- Goldman Disses Solar - Cramer's Stop Trading ! (10/7/08)
- Time to Hoard Cash - Cramer's Mad Money (10/6/08)
- Full list of Cramers Picks »
Trading Center
Hedge Fund Jobs
Job Seekers: Search jobs by category, get job alerts by email or live feed, apply online See full list of jobs »
Employers: See all recruitment options, get applications online or by email Post a job »
This article has 49 comments:
Slumping car sales are a back burner issue as penetration rates continue to increase and over any given period US car sales remain pretty constant with some years up and some down.
Mostly with a general bias up.
Also keep in mind that SDARS does not only go into american made vehicles. So I wouldn't over rate Ford and GM too heavily.
In any event, it really means very little as does the retail story until the issue of the merger is determined. You just can't mine the data for what it would mean going forward after a merger - period.
The i-pod story should not be overlooked. Sat rad on ANY portable device as part of a suscription becomes huge - especially for the Christmas season.
And, as I've always said, you will see a SDARS music library with subscriptions that include a set # of downloads per month with your subscription. This will be a huge marketing draw that I have seen no one mention at this point.
The NAB really does have a problem going forward as SDARS is destined to become ubiquitous. The recent i-pod story and the fact that it's making it into more and more cars everyday is driving the point home. The stocks got washed out with capitulation selling
and people are starting to understand that as well.
Upon the merger you'll start to see the forecasts ramp regarding all of the above. And the stock will climb as each and every brokerage firm will start recommending exposure to the industry for their clients.
There really will be some fireworks this July fourth. Count on it!
I hope common sense prevails. If the merger passes that doesn't even get these 2 companies out of the woods. They would just be another player in the digital music & info market. The fact that the NAB is trying to stop this merger is the clear proof that they don't want what? Competition! They do not in any way shape or form have the consumers best interest in mind. The bottom line is if the merger should pass the consumer is still in control. If I don't like the content for the price I can cancel my subscription and listen to FREE radio.
These cars travel up to 65 miles an hour and have very little maintenance engine costs.
If you get comcast internet go to the fan to see it in action.
Instead, you should focus on their growth prospects and profiitability (or lack thereof). These factors (and their absence) are what drive (or deplete) stock valuations.
I would urge you, Mr. Savery, if you wish to continue portraying yourself as a satellite radio expert, to change your approach by letting the facts draw the conclusion, rather than the other way around. Rather than focus on the merger, focus instead on the impending arrival of portable Internet radio and other forms of competition that will continue to erode subscriber growth, which has already slowed remarkably over the past year.
Tell us why cash-strapped car buyers (if you can even find one) would pony up $12 a month for a product they can get for free elsewhere?
There are also people that use solar power for their homes too, ask former Vice President Gore how that is working out. It was just released that that house now uses more power from the grid then it used to. The point is, it is fact that until solar gets to at least 76% it is not a viable source of energy. Just like wind, you would have to have wind turbines in 3 midwest states to be able to supply power to New York City alone. So like I said, it is not possible unless effieintcy improves a great deal which is still along way off. It has taken solar 20 years to get from 16% to 36% effinientcy.
No law against having golf cart batteries in your car either.
Fact is, it isn't that far off for the sunshine states. It's happening now!
So I wouldn't be so dire.
s
Tony Monaco
monacotv@sympatico.ca
ripped, Do you want to know why the news tells people not to trust all those thing like pills and pieces of equipment that will give you an extra 20 to 30 miles to the gallon for just a few dollars cost. Because if it were possible car companies would already be doing it just to sell their cars.
clearly some things simply get lost on you, or you simply choose not to see them. Whichever is the case, it matters little.
1. I have stated time and time again that S.A. does not pick up all articles I write. I have offered my opinions on many things that revolve around this sector.
2. I have spoken many times about services that are competition to satellite. I have stated quite readily that the Slacker Internet Radio service is something that satellite should consider trying to replicate for their music channels. In fact, I am a frequent Slacker user.
3. I have stated time and time again that I am not portraying myself as "the satellite radio expert". I have stated that I am a person who follows things closely and has an opinion. In post after post it is YOU that is calling me a "satellite radio expert, guru, etc." I do not know how much more clearly I can state this. Perhaps CAPS WILL HELP. I AM NOT A SATELLITE RADIO EXPERT. I AM SOMEONE WHO FOLLOWS THE SECTOR AND HAS OPINIONS.
4. SDARS has never made a profit. Most are already aware of this. To say that it is pure financials that drive the stock is a fools chase. People invest in SDARS because of potential. Right now the first item that deals with the potential is the merger. Most already know this.
Media will see large changes in the coming years. No one denies this. Satellite is simply one method of delivering content. Do you think all of this content will arrive for free? No, it will not. There is a lot of potential, and if one were to assume that, with Karmazin at the helm, the merger is the last stop they would be kidding themselves.
Why pay $13 per month when you can get something free you ask......
A poor question to say the least.
Why pay for a cell phone when you have a home phone. Why pay for cable tv? why pay for gas when you have a bike? Why pay for a restaurant steak when you can cook one at home? Why eat at del friscos when you can eat at wendy's?
The answer is that people either like the convenience or the product. If the subscriptions or revenues fall, then SDARS must either make changes or fail. Adjusting to the landscape is something that all companies must do.
cooper
here's a question: why watch "grey's anatomy" when you can watch the sopranos? why watch "how i met your mother" when you can watch "curb your enthusiasm"?
anyone who can't see how much BETTER sat radio is, is BLIND (or at least deaf.....)
as far as earnings? they'll come. as soon as they can get through the red tape created by the NAB, xm and sirius can move on with the business of making money. (and believe me - they will). siri is a stock that you either daytrade (super liquid) or buy, put in a drawer and pull out 5 years from now.
oh and vicar - remember: content is king. xm and sirius can afford the BEST, and i can't help to think that any internet radio company would be hard pressed to fund any content worth all that much. and as far as MUSIC goes, i think that they would be hard pressed to pay the royalties, either......
use your head, vicky, baby.
cooper
sorry.
:(
We've heard $1.75 by Wienkes, $5.00 by Kramer & a whopping $9.00 by Citi. Who's right, who's wrong and don't take the easy route by going with a middle number.
Need your professional opinions on this gentleman....thanks!
Jimy Da Saint
letsgodeep.com
passitdeep.com
On Jun 29 10:13 PM shure46 wrote:
> here's a weird thought ....since the value of the dollar has fallen
> ...shouldn't that make stocks pricier ????? I mean if Siri is at
> 2.00 with a devalued dollar .....compared to a few years back at
> 5.00 with a strong dollar ........possibly that means the stock sucks
> even worse than we think !!!!! BUT , it also means the stock may
> go up even higher than we predict !!!!!!! Bet that post didn't
> help anyone !!!!!!! hahahahahah heck , I just confused myself
> !!!!!
Tim... I liked your picture when you were 23.
Stick to technology, not stocks.
I'm going to say 3.20-3.60 tops within three weeks after announcement. Sadly, now that the FCC has jacked off for 8 overdue months (should have been done last fall) now you've got a market correction, tanking auto sales and 140-160 buck oil. FCC = useless schmucks.
It may take 2-3 weeks to hit it's top, then will slide back to 3.00 +/- .30 for the balance of the year. This shouldn't be sold on announcement as what Mel has to say, and the upgrades to be gained will take a few weeks to pee out.
so hydrogen and hibryd plug in cars will be in not more then 5 years like any other cars with large edvantage, even if states decide to subsedide at the beginining by giving very low taxes it will continue from there.There are already several countries, like, Israel and India that has plans of subsedising green cars.so hang on and be paciense.
Goldman's Sirius Call: Solid Thesis, Poor Timing
by: Mike Stathis posted on: June 29, 2008 | about stocks: MSFT / SIRI / SNE / XMSR / YHOO
*
Font Size:
*
Print
* Email
I just wanted to make something clear with all this talk about satellite radio. I'll be blunt. It's going nowhere. That is why I haven't followed Sirius (SIRI) or XM (XMSR) for several years. Why waste my time when I know how the game will turn out?
Let me explain. After releasing a research analysis on the sector in my newsletter in 2004-2005, I have not bothered to follow the satellite radio stocks because I already knew their longer-term fate. It's the same action I have taken on other companies that I predicted would go bankrupt or be sold on the cheap. And I have been right about all of them. It's not that I have a crystal ball or that I'm amazingly clever; it's just a matter of using some common sense combined with an understanding of business dynamics and competitive forces. I will summarize the main points of the 2004-2005 analysis I made on Sirius and the future of satellite radio:
Sirius will not make it. It will either go under or be sold on the auction block. Why? The industry has poor business dynamics as a standalone. It has high churn, short retention, and high customer acquisition costs. Only a diversified company can remain in this business. The wireless providers realized the need to secure a certain level of guaranteed revenues and they came up with contracts. The satellite radio business has not structured any value into their business that would allow them to drive revenues on a contractual basis. As a result, revenues are highly uncertain and will remain volatile, while net revenues per subscriber have little room for growth due to the high churn.
The enormous debt seen in Sirius and XM is just one indication of the poor business fundamentals of this quasi-sector. Just look at the profit and operating margins. These guys won't be able to turn a profit until they surpass 20 million subscribers. And that simply is not going to happen for a very long time if ever. As it stands today, Sirius is in much deeper trouble than XM. The company self-destructed by giving away most of its equity to its CEO and Howard Stern, as if the stock had little value.
It turns out that it didn't have much value. Even Stern apparently realized this and sold his stock.
While XM is fundamentally stronger and will emerge the winner, this won't last long. The big guys in media will force XM out when Internet is installed in autos which is coming in a few years. Yahoo (YHOO), Microsoft (MSFT) and others will offer free Internet radio as a way to seize the market. Then they will offer a paid service similar to satellite. This will steal away the customer base of the satellite providers. In the meantime, earnings from their other business lines will enable them to endure difficult transitional periods. If needed, the big media players will create a price war which Sirius and XM will not survive.
The only one's who will profit from Sirius are the CEO and Stern.
Things are playing out just as I predicted. Soon you will see how even the XM-Sirius combined entity gets destroyed when Internet radio enters the scene. The only thing that has changed in the four years since my report is that Yahoo has weakened and may not go forward with an Internet radio platform, at least for a while. But you can bet others will. If you do not understand the media war that has been going on now for several years, you really need to get up to speed. The big players in this war are Microsoft, Sony (SNE), Yahoo, some of the telecom and cable providers. The XM-Sirius entity will ultimately have to go up against these guys and they aren't going to win.
Now, will the combined XM-Sirius entity appreciate in price from here? I wouldn't doubt it. After all, many companies on a downward trend make short-term bounces. But that might only provide an exit for existing shareholders, as the odds of satellite radio surviving long-term are very slim. Internet radio is the future. And the only way satellite will play into the picture is through satellite-Internet radio, which will be a free service, with an optional paid service for no commercials. Once the paid service of XM-Sirius is knocked out, only then will the paid service model be a growing entity. And the only role XM-Sirius will play in this might be after being bought on the cheap by one of the big players.
You can bet Sirius is desperate for this merger to go through because they realize they're on their last leg. It's similar to the situation with Blockbuster (BBI) practically bending over backwards to merge with Circuit City (CC). Unlike XM, Circuit City has something to offer-a real business with a long history of profits and no debt (only seasonal borrowing or inventories). You can probably tell how I feel about any possible Circuit City-Blockbuster deal. But that's another story.
Only time will tell if I was completely right in my analysis. But one thing is for certain: those who read my report 4 years ago (quoted above) had a chance to bail out of XM and Sirius at $25 and $7 respectively.
Sirius was never a stock held by a large percentage of institutions because they realized the risks. I continue to notice the same investors who buy terrible stocks like Sirius have a habit of buying trash like Krispy Kreme (KKD) and a host of others. People, if you really want to play this investment game, you need to start figuring out these things on your own. Otherwise, leave the investing game to the pros because the really sharp guys out there know what's going on and they sure aren't going to tell you. And you cannot count on Wall Street to help you. While the Goldman analyst is dead right, I find it remarkable it took him so many years to issue this report. I'm not sure whether he just isn't that bright or his focus was on landing banking business. Most likely, it was the former since I still have not read any report that provides the insight I have.
Wall Street makes sure investors have a misguided sense of reality by issuing so many "Buy" ratings. Everywhere you look you see "experts" talk about how good it is to invest in the stock market but you never hear timely warnings when you should get out and wait for the next bull market. The refusal of Wall Street and those who control the media to even hint that there might be a period of a few years when you should stay out of the market is the reason why most investors get caught in bear markets.
Going forward, if you want to have a chance as an investor you're really going to need to change this mentality. Otherwise, the "do-it-yourself&q... approach is going to result in a disaster for many. Remember, the promoters of this fantasy – the online brokers – are just as guilty of this deceit as Wall Street. And they are making profits selling you this epiphany. So you might be better off buying ETFs.
Disclosure: None
On Jun 30 08:21 AM cos1000 wrote:
> shure46.....The US Markets are dollar based, foreign currencies are
> dollar based, as is oil and commodities. Look at the rise in foreign
> currencies / dollar and foreign markets / dollar. Our markets don't
> adjust all that much to fluctuations in the dollar but theirs do.
> Our markets Global Companies profit from the weak dollar, greater
> exports. I was following you for a bit until your melt down....LOL.
Gates has to put his money somewhere.
On Jun 30 10:17 PM cos1000 wrote:
> shure46......for the confusion, that you totally admit to be yours,
> you and your clan must follow the horses as we go into battle in
> support of the Blue Dog. The Bio Diesel bucket will be to right,
> pulled by the solar powered waste digester. Excuse me,....isn't this
> the alternative energy site??? Where's my wind powered GPS when I
> need it......All is good my friend, just found the medicinal wagon
> carrying hemp.