Help Wanted: Newspaper Classified Ad Sales Continue to Slide

by: Steve Wonsiewicz posted on: June 01, 2008 | about stocks: GCI / GHS / JRN / LEE / MEG / MNI / NYT / SSP / WPO    
  • Font Size:
  • Print

Declassified. That word, usually associated with top secret government documents, aptly describes what’s happening to the newspaper industry these days as publishers try to endure one of the worst markets for classified ad sales on record.

For newspaper investors, it means more pain than gain in 2008. That’s because the double-digit declines in classified ad revenue that plagued newspaper operators every quarter during 2007 are continuing well into 2008. Real estate, employment and automotive classifieds are in the tank and the fall-off isn’t showing any sign of abating, especially given the outlook during the rest of the year for high oil prices, slower consumer spending, weak jobs growth and depressed housing prices.

Newspaper publishers reported dismal classified ad sales in April, the latest period for which figures are available. For the month classifieds were down 29% at Media General (MEG), 28% at McClatchy (MNI), 23% at the New York Times Co. (NYT) and 20% in the U.S. for Gannett (GCI). That’s on top of similar declines during the first quarter of 2008. In all likelihood, the collapse in classified ad revenue will surpass the fall-off the newspaper industry experienced in the wake of the dot.com bust in 2001-2002 (see the Newspaper Association of America’s tally of ad sales here).

Stung by the steep declines in classified sales, advertising revenue at 10 of the country’s publicly traded newspaper companies fell 10% to $2.8 billion during the first three months of 2008 (see “Newspaper Industry – First Quarter Revenue Survey” here).

Print classified sales at the 10-company sample plummeted an estimated 24%, while local retail revenue slipped 8% and national sales dropped around 5%. Circulation revenue eased about 1%. Overall, total newspaper revenue at the 10 publishers decreased 8% to $3.8 billion.

Quick note: These aren’t “same-store sales” figures. They’re my estimates based on an analysis of the quarterly numbers reported by the companies. That said, because of the geographic and demographic diversity of the papers involved and the fact that there was minimal M&A activity during the periods reviewed, I believe it paints a pretty accurate portrait of the health of the newspaper industry.

With the fat margins associated with classified ads slipping away, publishers are watching cash flow drop precipitously. EBITDA at stand-alone newspaper operators fell 24% during the first quarter, while EBITDA at the newspaper divisions of larger media companies was down 21%. On average, EBITDA margins slid on average about 300 basis points for the 10-company sample during the quarter.

For value- and income-oriented investors, the steep stock price declines and corresponding high dividend yields make newspaper stocks a tempting contrarian play. But until there’s greater visibility on the ad sales front, I’d look elsewhere for investment opportunities. 

Disclosure: I don’t own shares of newspaper stocks.

This article has 6 comments! Add yours below...

Steve Wonsiewicz

About this author:
Become a Contributor Submit an Article

This article has 6 comments:

  •  
    Joe
    Jun 01 01:01 PM
    If interested in a look back on the press:
    there is a film clip on You Tube, done sixty or more years ago. It's
    either an ad for becoming a journalist or the press were describing
    themselves to general public, how they work, what they are doing.
    Sense of humor?
    The search word on You Tube - no typing mistake - /10.38 min:
    "old skool journalism film"
    (hope it's ok to point that out here)
  •  
    John
    Pseudonym
    Jun 02 12:34 AM
    Back in the early days of ebay, I knew classifieds were dead.

    They had a chance to be the "local ebay" but they stuck their head in the sand and kept repeating "this internet thing will die".

    Well, they're the ones dying...

    The day can still be saved, but I'll let them figure it out...
  •  
    Gu Be
    Jun 02 01:00 PM
    Newspapers should combine website internet classified with the printed ones with a program lowering strongly the advertising rates and putting the classified on a dayly newsletter to all its subscribers.
    This last step would increase the interest of the readers in the ads and using the classified at much lower prices (extremely low prices suggested and reduced fidelization rates).
  •  
    rodneyford
    Jun 18 02:13 PM
    My Website
    LOAN OFFER HERE,APPLY NOW

    Are you eager to secure funds for that dream project of yours?
    Do you have a viable business but lack the necessary finances to get it off it’s feet?
    Do you have ideas which worth millions but you lack the necessary capital to put your idea to test?
    Have you been turned down by other lenders?
    Do you desire a house but you lack enough cash to acquire it?
    Do you want your dream car now and yet you can’t, just because of your financial status?
    rodney ford lending firm is granting you the opportunity to actualize your dream.
    If you are interested in obtaining a loan,kindly contact us through the below email address for your loan request:
    rcdneyfordff@yahoo.com
  •  
    mr blair
    james
    Jun 26 03:15 PM
    Private Loan Investment Company is offering outs loans to the public with a very low rate of 3%. We offer out personal and business loans.look no further contact Private Loan Investment Company today on E-mail:privateloaninve... . We loan from $5,000 to $50,000,000 with a maximum time duration of 30years.
    Contact us with borrowers information below:
    Full Name:
    Sex:
    Location:
    Amount Needed:
    Monthly Income:

    Best Regards,
    Mr Blair James.
  •  
    vinard
    fisayo
    Jul 23 07:35 AM
    We have got money to lend out to serious and prosprctive customers and all kind of business firms.Email:vinfinanci...
Loading...
Symbols:
Authors:
Quick Links:

ETFs In Focus

  • Long Ideas

  • Short Ideas

  • Cramer's Picks